Monday, November 1, 2010

If you didn't resist, you must have wanted it!

Courtesy of Claire, here's a very interesting article drawing parallels between the way courts traditionally and - er...modernly? - approach rape cases and 4th Amendment cases.
...there are many parallels to be drawn between rape and Fourth Amendment consent law. Although both claim to protect the dignity of choice, like rape law, the Fourth Amendment fails to ask if a subject wishes to be seized or touched, focusing instead on the amount of force and coercion used by the police. Also like rape law, the Fourth Amendment fails to recognize that subtle forms of coercion are incompatible with true consent. Both Fourth Amendment and rape law blame subjects who submit to subtle coercion, telling them they had a choice. Just as rape victims were told they asked for it by wearing short dresses and not screaming for help, individuals are told they asked for it by extending their arms to be searched.

1 comment:

Jeffersonian said...

And if you do resist you get Erik Scotted.